The editorial workflow of Educational Review: Research and Innovation (ERRI) is designed to ensure transparency, accountability, academic integrity, and compliance with international publication ethics throughout the manuscript lifecycle. Every submission is evaluated fairly through a rigorous editorial screening, double-blind peer review process, and quality assurance procedures before publication.

---

1. Submission Handling

All manuscripts must be submitted electronically through the Open Journal Systems (OJS) platform. Submissions sent by email or through any other communication channels will not be considered for publication.

Requirement	Description
Submission System	Open Journal Systems (OJS)
Accepted Method	Online submission only
Not Accepted	Email submissions or other unofficial channels

---

2. Initial Technical Screening

The Managing Editor performs an initial technical assessment to ensure that all submitted manuscripts comply with the journal's editorial requirements before entering the peer review process.

Screening Criteria	Description
Author Guidelines Compliance	Verification of manuscript preparation according to ERRI Author Guidelines.
Submission Completeness	Confirmation that all required files and metadata have been submitted.
Formatting Review	Evaluation of manuscript structure, references, tables, and figures.
Similarity Screening	Plagiarism detection using recognized similarity-checking software.
Possible Outcomes	Return for technical revision or Desk Rejection.

---

3. Scope and Academic Quality Assessment

The Editor-in-Chief evaluates whether the manuscript is appropriate for ERRI before assigning it to a Section Editor.

Assessment Area	Description
Journal Scope	Alignment with ERRI's aims and scope.
Academic Quality	Minimum scholarly standards and originality.
Research Contribution	Potential contribution to educational research and innovation.
Outcome	Proceed to peer review or Desk Rejection.

---

4. Editorial Assignment

Eligible manuscripts are assigned to an appropriate Section Editor according to subject expertise.

Section Editor Responsibilities	Description
Peer Review Coordination	Selects qualified reviewers and manages the review process.
Communication	Communicates with authors and reviewers throughout the editorial process.
Recommendation	Provides editorial recommendations to the Editor-in-Chief.

---

5. Editorial Decision-Making

Editorial decisions are based on scholarly merit, reviewer recommendations, methodological rigor, originality, and adherence to publication ethics.

Decision Criteria	Description
Reviewer Reports	Recommendations from independent reviewers.
Scientific Merit	Originality and contribution to knowledge.
Methodological Quality	Research design and analytical rigor.
Publication Ethics	Compliance with ethical publishing standards.
Possible Decisions	Accept, Minor Revision, Major Revision, or Reject.

The Editor-in-Chief retains full authority over all final editorial decisions.

---

6. Revision Management

Authors receiving revision requests are expected to submit a revised manuscript together with a detailed response to reviewers explaining how each comment has been addressed.

Editorial Verification	Description
Reviewer Comments	Verification that all comments have been addressed.
Quality Improvement	Assessment of manuscript improvements.
Response Letter	Evaluation of author responses.
Possible Outcome	Further revision, acceptance, or rejection.

---

7. Production Process

Accepted manuscripts proceed to professional production prior to publication.

Production Stage	Description
Copyediting	Language editing and consistency according to journal style.
Proofreading	Final editorial quality check.
Layout Editing	Preparation of publication-ready PDF, HTML, and metadata.
Author Proof	Authors review and approve final proofs before publication.

---

8. Publication

Following final approval, articles are published online as open-access publications.

Publication Activity	Description
DOI Registration	Digital Object Identifier assigned through Crossref.
Open Access	Immediate online availability without subscription barriers.
Indexing & Archiving	Metadata distribution and long-term digital preservation.

---

9. Editorial Responsibilities

Editors are expected to maintain the highest standards of editorial professionalism and publication ethics.

• Maintain confidentiality throughout the editorial process.
• Ensure fair, objective, and unbiased manuscript evaluation.
• Manage conflicts of interest appropriately.
• Uphold international publication ethics and research integrity.
• Never use unpublished materials for personal research or benefit.
• Never discriminate against authors based on nationality, gender, institutional affiliation, religion, or political beliefs.

---

10. Conflict of Interest Management

Editors shall recuse themselves from handling manuscripts whenever a conflict of interest exists, including but not limited to:

• Institutional affiliation.
• Personal or family relationships.
• Research collaboration.
• Financial or professional interests.

In such circumstances, responsibility for editorial handling will be assigned to another qualified editor.

---

11. Ethical Oversight

ERRI follows the Committee on Publication Ethics (COPE) Core Practices in managing ethical issues throughout the publication process.

• Handling complaints and appeals.
• Investigating allegations of research misconduct.
• Managing plagiarism and duplicate publication.
• Issuing corrections, retractions, and expressions of concern when appropriate.

---

12. Transparency and Accountability

All editorial activities are documented within the Open Journal Systems (OJS) platform to ensure transparency, accountability, and traceability throughout the editorial process.

Principle	Description
Traceability	Complete documentation of editorial actions.
Accountability	Editorial decisions remain auditable and verifiable.
Transparency	Clear documentation of manuscript handling from submission to publication.

---

Educational Review: Research and Innovation (ERRI)
Committed to Excellence, Integrity, and Innovation in Educational Research.